Plan B and the moment of conception
Aug. 28th, 2006 11:51 amI should put my own biases on the table here: Personally, I believe, for involved, more or less consequentialist reasons, that abortion should be legal, free of statutory encumbrances, and easy to get under all circumstances, up to the moment of birth. But I know that this isn't a popular position in America, even among people who generally support reproductive rights; I recognize that it is a difficult issue and I can sympathize with people who have moral qualms about late abortions.
Objections to abortion are sometimes phrased in terms of slippery slopes: if you support abortion under circumstance X then it's not a big stretch to support infanticide under circumstance Y, and where should we draw the line? (Most extravagantly, Philip K. Dick once wrote a misogynistic short story in which abortion had been extended to an option to kill your children up to the point where they learn algebra.)
In practice, though, nobody of consequence is advocating infanticide, and the true political slippery slope in the US slips the other way. Anti-abortion activists are turning their attention to bans and restrictions on various methods of contraception. This is logically perverse even from a hardline anti-abortion point of view, since a likely consequence of restricting contraception is to increase the rate of abortion, but it's happening.
( Musings about Plan B and its opposition )
Objections to abortion are sometimes phrased in terms of slippery slopes: if you support abortion under circumstance X then it's not a big stretch to support infanticide under circumstance Y, and where should we draw the line? (Most extravagantly, Philip K. Dick once wrote a misogynistic short story in which abortion had been extended to an option to kill your children up to the point where they learn algebra.)
In practice, though, nobody of consequence is advocating infanticide, and the true political slippery slope in the US slips the other way. Anti-abortion activists are turning their attention to bans and restrictions on various methods of contraception. This is logically perverse even from a hardline anti-abortion point of view, since a likely consequence of restricting contraception is to increase the rate of abortion, but it's happening.
( Musings about Plan B and its opposition )